N※N

Show House and Home Publications

Housing market 'purgatory' for existing home sales as activity falls to lowest level in 9 months

Housing Market Trapped in Purgatory: Existing Home Sales Plunge Amid Stubborn Mortgage Rates

The U.S. housing market remains mired in a state of limbo, with existing home sales hitting new lows in June as high mortgage rates continue to deter both buyers and sellers. This ongoing stagnation, often described by economists as a "purgatory" for real estate, shows no immediate signs of relief, painting a picture of a sector caught between economic pressures and hesitant consumer behavior. As potential homebuyers grapple with affordability challenges and current homeowners cling to their low-rate mortgages, the market's vital signs—sales volume, inventory levels, and price trends—reveal a landscape frozen in uncertainty.

June's existing home sales data, released by the National Association of Realtors (NAR), underscored the depth of this malaise. Sales of previously owned homes fell to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of just 3.89 million units, marking a 5.4% decline from May and a staggering 5.4% drop compared to the same month a year earlier. This figure represents the lowest level since December of the previous year, highlighting a persistent downward trend that has plagued the market for months. The median sales price, meanwhile, climbed to a record $426,900, up 4.1% from the prior year, illustrating the paradoxical nature of the current environment: prices are rising even as transaction volumes plummet.

Experts attribute this disconnect to the infamous "lock-in effect," where homeowners who secured mortgages at historically low rates during the pandemic era are reluctant to sell. With the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate hovering around 6.8%—down slightly from peaks above 7% but still more than double the sub-3% rates seen in 2021—many would-be sellers face the prospect of trading their affordable loans for much costlier ones. This hesitation has led to a severe inventory shortage, with only about 1.32 million homes available for sale at the end of June, equivalent to a 4.1-month supply at the current sales pace. That's an improvement from the razor-thin inventories of recent years, but still well below the 5-6 months considered balanced by industry standards.

NAR's chief economist, Lawrence Yun, didn't mince words in his assessment. "We're seeing a market where buyers are increasingly priced out, and sellers are staying put," he noted. "The result is a purgatory-like state where activity is suppressed, and the usual seasonal upticks in summer sales are nowhere to be found." Yun pointed out that first-time buyers, who typically make up about a third of the market, accounted for only 29% of purchases in June, squeezed by high prices and elevated borrowing costs. All-cash transactions, often a sign of investor activity or wealthier buyers bypassing mortgages, rose to 28% of sales, further sidelining average households.

This isn't just a statistical anomaly; it's a symptom of broader economic forces at play. The Federal Reserve's aggressive rate-hiking campaign, aimed at taming inflation that peaked at over 9% in mid-2022, has rippled through the housing sector with unintended consequences. While inflation has cooled to around 3%, the lag in monetary policy effects means mortgage rates remain elevated, tied closely to the 10-year Treasury yield. Fed Chair Jerome Powell has hinted at potential rate cuts later this year, but uncertainty lingers amid mixed economic signals, including a resilient job market and persistent wage growth.

Regional variations add layers to the national picture. In the Northeast, sales dropped 2.1% month-over-month, with prices surging 9.7% year-over-year to a median of $521,500. The South, the largest region by volume, saw a steeper 5.9% decline in sales, though its median price rose more modestly by 2.3% to $374,300. The Midwest and West experienced similar slumps, with sales down 8% and 2.6%, respectively, and prices climbing in tandem. These disparities reflect local factors like migration patterns, job growth, and housing stock availability, but the overarching theme is one of caution and restraint.

Beyond the numbers, the human impact is profound. Prospective buyers like Sarah Thompson, a 32-year-old teacher from Atlanta, embody the frustration felt by many. "We've been saving for years, but with rates this high, the monthly payments are just out of reach," she shared. "We're stuck renting, watching prices go up while we wait for some relief." On the seller side, homeowners like Mike Rivera in Denver are holding off. "I refinanced at 2.8% two years ago—why would I give that up for a 7% mortgage on a new place?" he asked. This sentiment is echoed in surveys, with a recent Redfin report indicating that 80% of homeowners with mortgages below 5% have no plans to sell anytime soon.

The ripple effects extend to related industries. Homebuilders, facing less competition from existing homes, have ramped up new construction, with housing starts up modestly in recent months. Yet even here, challenges persist: high material costs and labor shortages are keeping new home prices elevated, around a median of $417,300 in June. Real estate agents report slower business, with commissions squeezed by fewer transactions. Mortgage lenders, too, are feeling the pinch, as origination volumes remain depressed.

Looking ahead, forecasts offer a glimmer of hope mixed with realism. Many economists predict that if the Fed begins cutting rates in September, as some market watchers anticipate, mortgage rates could dip below 6% by year's end, potentially unlocking more inventory and boosting sales. Fannie Mae projects existing home sales to total about 4.1 million for the year, a slight uptick from last year's lows but still far from the 6 million-plus seen in boom times. However, risks abound: a resurgence in inflation or geopolitical tensions could keep rates high, prolonging the purgatory.

Some analysts argue for structural changes to break the impasse. Proposals include expanding affordable housing initiatives, reforming zoning laws to increase supply, and offering incentives for first-time buyers, such as down payment assistance or tax credits. "The market needs more than just lower rates; it needs systemic fixes to address decades of underbuilding," said Danielle Hale, chief economist at Realtor.com. "Without that, we could be in this holding pattern for years."

In the meantime, the housing market's purgatory serves as a microcosm of broader economic anxieties. It's a sector where dreams of homeownership collide with the harsh realities of interest rates and affordability, leaving millions in a state of suspended animation. As summer fades into fall, all eyes will be on the Fed's next moves, hoping for a catalyst that could finally usher in redemption—or at least a path out of limbo.

This stagnation isn't without its silver linings. For those who can afford to buy now, the lack of bidding wars means more negotiating power, and some markets are seeing price concessions from motivated sellers. Investors, particularly in rental properties, are finding opportunities in the low-turnover environment. But for the average American, the wait continues, a testament to how deeply intertwined housing is with the nation's economic health.

As we delve deeper into the implications, it's worth examining historical parallels. The current slowdown echoes the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, when sales plummeted amid foreclosures and tight credit. Yet today's market differs: there's no glut of distressed properties; instead, it's a supply drought. Pre-pandemic norms saw annual sales around 5-6 million, fueled by low rates and millennial demand. The shift post-2020, with remote work and urban exodus, initially supercharged activity, but the rate reversal has reversed those gains.

Demographic trends add another dimension. Baby boomers, many of whom own homes outright or with low mortgages, are aging in place rather than downsizing, further constricting supply. Millennials and Gen Z, burdened by student debt and high rents, struggle to enter the market. Immigration patterns, too, influence demand, with newcomers often seeking affordable housing in suburbs and exurbs.

Policy responses could accelerate change. The Biden administration has pushed for measures like the Neighborhood Homes Investment Act to spur development in underserved areas, while some states experiment with rent control and inclusionary zoning. However, political gridlock in Washington may delay meaningful action, especially in an election year.

In conclusion, the June existing home sales report is more than a data point—it's a snapshot of a market in flux, trapped between past lows and future possibilities. Until mortgage rates ease and inventory builds, this purgatory will persist, challenging the American dream of homeownership and testing the resilience of an industry at the heart of the economy. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full Fortune Article at:
[ https://fortune.com/2025/07/28/housing-market-purgatory-existing-home-sales-june-real-estate-mortgage-rates/ ]