Wed, March 25, 2026
Tue, March 24, 2026

Seneca County Home Sales: Nov 2024 Overview

Recent Sales Overview (Nov. 15-21, 2024)

The data indicates sales prices ranging from a low of $135,000 for a property on Route 14 N in Seneca Falls to a high of $300,000 for a home on Church Street, also in Seneca Falls. The median sale price for this period was approximately $230,000. Property taxes varied depending on location and assessed value, ranging from $2,736 to $3,896 annually. It's crucial to note that these figures represent a snapshot in time and should be considered in the context of broader market dynamics.

AddressCitySale PriceProperty Taxes
1189 Route 14 NSeneca Falls$135,000$3,289
6531 Hurlbut StSeneca Falls$164,900$2,736
4625 Wood LnWaterloo$177,000$2,934
4169 County Rd 18Seneca Falls$180,000$2,970
3566 Route 31 SGeneva$199,900$2,921
6864 New StSeneca Falls$205,000$2,990
4291 Slayton RdPhelps$219,900$3,318
1375 Rt 31Geneva$230,000$3,463
4195 Route 14 SSeneca Falls$245,000$3,507
5697 Perkins RdSeneca Falls$249,000$3,711
2512 Pre Emption RdPhelps$269,000$3,331
2147 County Rd 1Geneva$285,000$3,591
4828 Miller RdWaterloo$289,000$3,601
1990 Hickory Hill RdGeneva$290,000$3,518
4350 Church StSeneca Falls$300,000$3,896

Broader Market Trends in Seneca County

Over the past two years, Seneca County has experienced moderate, but consistent, growth in home values. This growth is fueled by several factors, including increasing demand from individuals and families seeking a more affordable and rural lifestyle compared to larger metropolitan areas like Rochester and Syracuse. The Finger Lakes region's appeal - its scenic beauty, wineries, outdoor recreation opportunities, and proximity to these cities - continues to attract buyers. A significant influx of remote workers, a trend accelerated by the pandemic, has further boosted demand.

However, inventory remains a key challenge. The number of homes available for sale in Seneca County has been relatively low, creating a competitive market for buyers and contributing to upward pressure on prices. While new construction is underway in certain areas, it hasn't yet been sufficient to significantly alleviate the inventory shortage.

Town-Specific Nuances

Each town within Seneca County presents its own unique characteristics. Geneva, with its larger population and proximity to Hobart and William Smith Colleges, often commands higher prices, particularly for properties near the lake. Seneca Falls benefits from its historical significance and tourism industry, attracting buyers interested in quaint downtown living. Waterloo offers a more rural setting with larger properties, while Phelps provides a balance between affordability and access to amenities.

Property Taxes: A Critical Consideration

The provided data highlights the importance of considering property taxes when evaluating potential home purchases. These taxes can significantly impact monthly housing costs. While the figures shown are for specific properties, it's important for buyers to research tax rates for different towns and school districts within Seneca County to understand the full financial implications.

Looking Ahead: Projections for 2026

Experts predict that the Seneca County real estate market will remain competitive throughout 2026. While the rate of price appreciation may moderate slightly due to rising interest rates, demand is expected to remain strong. The key will be monitoring inventory levels. If inventory continues to remain constrained, prices are likely to continue to climb, albeit at a slower pace.

Buyers are advised to be prepared to move quickly, secure pre-approval for financing, and consider making competitive offers. Sellers can expect a favorable market, but should price their homes strategically to attract qualified buyers. It is predicted that the average sale price across the county will climb approximately 3-5% by the end of 2026, but this is heavily dependent on interest rate fluctuations and overall economic conditions.


Read the Full syracuse.com Article at:
[ https://www.syracuse.com/realestate-news/2025/11/seneca-county-real-estate-see-all-homes-sold-nov-15-nov-21.html ]