N※N

Perth Risk Report Kept Confidential, Sparking Transparency Debate

  //house-home.news-articles.net/content/2026/02/0 .. t-confidential-sparking-transparency-debate.html
  Published in House and Home on Wednesday, February 4th 2026 at 17:40 GMT by The West Australian
      Locales: Western Australia, AUSTRALIA

Perth, Western Australia - February 4th, 2026 - A crucial risk assessment report detailing significant governance and financial challenges within the City of Perth will remain confidential, a decision that has ignited a fierce debate about transparency and accountability in local government. Compiled by the State Government, the report's contents are deemed too sensitive for public release, citing ongoing investigations and potential legal consequences. This move has drawn sharp criticism from opposition councillors and the public, who argue for open access to information concerning the management of their city.

The report, which is scheduled to be discussed in a closed-door session next week, is expected to paint a detailed picture of the City of Perth's financial health, internal governance processes, and effectiveness of its risk management procedures. Duncan Ord, the State Government's Director-General of Local Government, defended the decision to withhold the report, stating that its release would "compromise ongoing investigations and potential legal action." He emphasized the legally sensitive nature of the information contained within, suggesting that premature disclosure could jeopardize any future proceedings.

However, the justification has failed to quell the growing discontent. Dr. Peter Newman, leader of the opposition and a current City of Perth councillor, has strongly condemned the decision, labelling it a deliberate "cover-up." Dr. Newman argues that the public deserves full disclosure regarding the issues affecting their local council and accuses the State Government of attempting to conceal the extent of the problems. He believes a lack of transparency breeds distrust and hinders the ability of citizens to hold their elected officials accountable.

This isn't the first time concerns have been raised regarding the City of Perth's operations. Over the past several years, the council has faced scrutiny over a series of issues, including questionable procurement practices, delays in major infrastructure projects, and disagreements among councillors. While specific details remain shrouded in secrecy, sources within the council suggest the current risk report delves into these areas and potentially uncovers further irregularities. Several councillors, speaking off the record, have confirmed the report's findings are indeed concerning but have been instructed to refrain from public comment.

The decision to keep the report confidential sets a concerning precedent, according to transparency advocates. They argue that while legitimate legal concerns must be respected, a blanket refusal to release information undermines the principles of open government and democratic participation. They suggest that redacting sensitive details - names, specific evidence relating to ongoing investigations - could allow for a more transparent approach without compromising legal proceedings. The current stance, critics say, effectively silences dissenting voices within the council and prevents the public from engaging in informed debate.

The ramifications extend beyond mere public relations. The City of Perth plays a vital role in the economic and social fabric of Western Australia. A financially unstable or poorly governed council could have far-reaching consequences for businesses, residents, and the broader state economy. Concerns are mounting that ongoing issues are impacting the council's ability to effectively deliver essential services, such as waste management, infrastructure maintenance, and community programs.

The upcoming confidential session is expected to be tense, with councillors likely to demand further explanation from State Government officials regarding the rationale for withholding the report. While a full public release appears unlikely in the immediate future, pressure is mounting for a compromise solution that allows for greater transparency without jeopardizing ongoing investigations. Local residents are beginning to organize petitions and online campaigns, demanding access to the report and a full accounting of the council's financial and governance practices. The situation raises broader questions about the oversight of local government in Western Australia and the need for stronger mechanisms to ensure accountability and transparency. The State Government is facing increasing calls for a comprehensive review of its policies regarding the release of information related to local councils. Whether this will happen remains to be seen, but the current impasse has undoubtedly damaged public trust and fueled speculation about the true extent of the problems plaguing the City of Perth.