N※N

Historic Over-the-Rhine Row House with Private Courtyard Listed for $2 Million

  //house-home.news-articles.net/content/2026/01/0 .. with-private-courtyard-listed-for-2-million.html
  Published in House and Home on Friday, January 2nd 2026 at 3:27 GMT by The Cincinnati Enquirer

A Rare Oasis: Historic Over-the-Rhine Row House with Private Courtyard Listed for $2 Million

Cincinnati’s historic Over-the-Rhine (OTR) neighborhood continues to draw attention – not just for its revitalization but also for the unique, often stunning properties that emerge on the market. The latest example is a meticulously restored row house at 1309 Vine Street, currently listed for $2 million, representing a significant investment in one of Cincinnati's most desirable locales. The property’s appeal lies not only in its architectural significance and luxurious updates but also in something increasingly rare: a substantial, private courtyard oasis within the bustling urban landscape.

The house itself is a testament to OTR’s rich history, dating back to 1869. Built during a period of significant growth for Cincinnati as a major industrial hub, the row houses along Vine Street were originally constructed to house prosperous merchants and professionals who worked in the burgeoning downtown area. The architecture reflects this era – Italianate style with intricate brickwork, tall windows designed to maximize natural light (a crucial consideration before widespread electricity), and detailed cornices that speak of a time when craftsmanship was paramount.

The current owners, identified as Jason and Sarah Bensing, acquired the property in 2019 and embarked on an extensive renovation project. While preserving the original character and historic fabric of the building, they incorporated modern amenities and design elements to create a truly exceptional residence. The Cincinnati Historic Conservation Society played a role in ensuring the renovations adhered to strict guidelines aimed at maintaining the neighborhood's historical integrity. This careful balance between preservation and modernization is key to the property’s value and appeal.

The house boasts approximately 4,100 square feet of living space spread across three floors, with five bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms. Interior details highlight both the original craftsmanship and the Bensings' commitment to high-end finishes. Original hardwood flooring has been meticulously restored, exposed brick walls add industrial charm, and custom millwork throughout creates a sense of bespoke elegance. The kitchen is a particular standout, featuring state-of-the-art appliances, custom cabinetry, and an island perfect for entertaining. The home also includes a wine cellar, adding to its appeal for discerning buyers.

However, the true jewel of this property is undoubtedly the courtyard. Spanning roughly 25 feet wide by 100 feet deep, it’s a remarkably large private space – a rarity in OTR where land is at a premium and properties are tightly packed together. The courtyard features mature landscaping, including trees and flowering shrubs, creating a secluded and tranquil atmosphere. A stone patio provides ample room for outdoor dining and relaxation, while the high walls offer privacy from the surrounding streetscape. According to listing agent Chris Fenneman of Coldwell Banker Realty, this private oasis is one of the key selling points, representing an incredibly valuable amenity in such a densely populated urban area.

The price point – $2 million – reflects not only the quality of the renovations and the desirable location but also the scarcity of properties with such significant outdoor space in OTR. While Cincinnati's real estate market has seen fluctuations, luxury properties in established historic neighborhoods like OTR consistently hold their value. OTR’s ongoing revitalization continues to drive demand for high-end housing, fueled by a desire among residents for urban living combined with historical charm and convenient access to restaurants, entertainment, and cultural attractions.

The article also touches on the broader context of OTR's transformation. Once facing decades of decline and disinvestment, the neighborhood has undergone a remarkable resurgence in recent years. Significant public and private investment has led to the restoration of historic buildings, the construction of new housing, and the influx of trendy restaurants, bars, and shops. This revitalization has made OTR one of Cincinnati's most sought-after neighborhoods, attracting both young professionals and established families. The Bensings’ decision to sell now reflects a confluence of factors – potentially including personal circumstances or recognizing peak market conditions – but also underscores the ongoing desirability of OTR real estate.

The listing highlights that while OTR has seen considerable investment and development, preserving its historic character remains paramount. Properties like 1309 Vine Street serve as tangible reminders of Cincinnati's past, offering a unique opportunity to own a piece of history within a vibrant and evolving urban landscape. The combination of luxury, privacy, and historical significance makes this row house with its private courtyard an exceptional offering in the Cincinnati market.

[ https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2026/01/02/otr-row-house-with-private-courtyard-on-the-market-for-2m/87958000007/ ]