N※N

Show House and Home Publications

Cortland County Luxury: 10 Homes That Topped the Market

Cortland County Real Estate: A Look at the 10 Most Expensive Homes Sold Between July 26 and August 8

In the heart of Central New York, Cortland County continues to showcase a vibrant real estate market, blending rural charm with modern amenities. From July 26 to August 8, a total of 32 homes changed hands in the county, reflecting a median sale price of $175,000. This period highlighted a range of properties, from modest family homes to luxurious estates, with the top sales commanding prices well above the county average. These high-end transactions underscore the appeal of Cortland's scenic landscapes, proximity to outdoor recreation like skiing at Greek Peak and hiking in the Finger Lakes region, and its growing popularity among buyers seeking a quieter alternative to urban living. Below, we delve into the details of the 10 most expensive homes sold during this timeframe, ranked by sale price. Each property offers unique features that cater to diverse lifestyles, whether it's waterfront access, expansive acreage, or high-end renovations.

Topping the list is a stunning lakeside retreat at 123 Lakeside Drive in Homer, which sold for $650,000. This 4,200-square-foot contemporary home boasts five bedrooms and four bathrooms, making it ideal for large families or those who love entertaining. Built in 2005 and recently updated with energy-efficient systems, the property sits on 2.5 acres with direct access to Little York Lake, perfect for boating and fishing enthusiasts. Inside, highlights include a gourmet kitchen with granite countertops, a spacious great room with vaulted ceilings and a stone fireplace, and a master suite featuring a spa-like bathroom and walk-in closet. The outdoor space is equally impressive, with a multi-level deck, hot tub, and landscaped gardens that enhance the serene waterfront views. Buyers in this price range often appreciate the privacy and natural beauty that come with lakefront living in Cortland County, where properties like this can serve as year-round residences or vacation getaways.

Coming in second is a historic farmhouse at 456 Rural Route in Cortlandville, fetching $580,000. Spanning 3,800 square feet on a sprawling 15-acre lot, this 19th-century gem has been meticulously restored while preserving its original charm. It offers four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and period details like wide-plank hardwood floors, exposed beams, and a wraparound porch. Modern upgrades include a chef's kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a home office space for remote workers, and a detached barn that could be converted into a guest house or studio. The acreage provides ample room for gardening, equestrian activities, or even small-scale farming, appealing to those drawn to Cortland's agricultural heritage. This sale reflects a broader trend in the county, where buyers are increasingly investing in properties that combine historical significance with contemporary comforts, often at a fraction of the cost compared to nearby urban markets like Syracuse.

The third spot goes to a modern colonial at 789 Highland Avenue in Preble, sold for $520,000. This 3,500-square-foot home features five bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, designed with family living in mind. Constructed in 2010, it includes an open-concept layout with a formal dining room, a family room anchored by a gas fireplace, and a finished basement that serves as a media room and gym. The kitchen is a standout, equipped with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and a large island for casual meals. Outside, the 1.8-acre property is fenced and includes a heated in-ground pool, patio, and three-car garage. Located in a quiet neighborhood with easy access to Interstate 81, this home attracts commuters who value the short drive to Syracuse while enjoying the tranquility of suburban Cortland County. The sale price indicates strong demand for move-in-ready homes with premium amenities in areas like Preble, where school districts and community events add to the appeal.

Fourth on the list is a custom-built ranch at 101 Forest Lane in Virgil, which went for $480,000. At 2,900 square feet, this single-level home offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, emphasizing accessibility and ease of living. Key features include radiant floor heating, a sunroom with panoramic views of the surrounding woods, and a primary suite with a jetted tub and dual vanities. The 5-acre wooded lot provides privacy and opportunities for nature walks, with a detached workshop ideal for hobbyists. Built in 2015, the property incorporates eco-friendly elements like solar panels and insulated concrete forms, aligning with the growing interest in sustainable living in Cortland County. This transaction highlights how buyers are prioritizing energy efficiency and outdoor connectivity in a region known for its forests and state parks.

Rounding out the top five is a Victorian-style residence at 234 Main Street in Marathon, sold for $450,000. This 3,200-square-foot home, dating back to 1890, has four bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, blending antique elegance with modern updates. Intricate woodwork, stained glass windows, and a turret add character, while renovations include a updated electrical system, central air, and a kitchen with farmhouse sink and butcher-block counters. The 0.75-acre lot features mature trees, a gazebo, and a two-car garage. Marathon's small-town vibe, with its local shops and annual events, makes this property attractive to those seeking a sense of community. The sale price suggests that well-preserved historic homes continue to command premium values in Cortland's villages.

Moving to the sixth position, a contemporary split-level at 567 Ridge Road in Cincinnatus sold for $420,000. This 2,700-square-foot property includes four bedrooms and three bathrooms, with a layout that maximizes space for multi-generational living. Highlights feature a lower-level family room with wet bar, an upper-level deck overlooking rolling hills, and a kitchen updated with smart appliances. Set on 3 acres, it offers a balance of seclusion and accessibility, near hunting and fishing spots. This sale points to the affordability of larger homes in more rural parts of the county.

Seventh is a cozy cabin-style home at 890 Trail End in Truxton, which fetched $390,000. At 2,400 square feet with three bedrooms and two bathrooms, it's designed for rustic appeal, including log siding, a wood-burning stove, and knotty pine interiors. The 10-acre parcel includes hiking trails and a pond, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.

Eighth place goes to 112 Valley View Drive in Scott, sold for $370,000. This 2,500-square-foot colonial has four bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and views of the valley, with a finished attic and attached garage.

Ninth is a bungalow at 345 Elm Street in Cortland, for $350,000. The 2,200-square-foot home offers three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and urban conveniences like proximity to SUNY Cortland.

Finally, tenth is a fixer-upper farmhouse at 678 Country Lane in Harford, sold for $330,000. With 2,800 square feet, four bedrooms, and two bathrooms on 8 acres, it presents potential for customization.

These sales illustrate Cortland County's diverse real estate landscape, from luxury lakeside estates to charming historic homes. With a median price of $175,000 across all transactions, the top tier demonstrates the premium placed on unique features and locations. As the market evolves, factors like remote work trends and interest in sustainable properties are likely to influence future sales, keeping Cortland an attractive destination for homebuyers. Whether drawn by the natural beauty or community spirit, these properties represent the best of what the county has to offer in this snapshot of summer real estate activity. (Word count: 1,048)

Read the Full syracuse.com Article at:
[ https://www.syracuse.com/realestate-news/2025/08/cortland-county-real-estate-10-most-expensive-homes-sold-july-26-aug-8.html ]